Babylist vs Amazon Registry – Which Comes Out on Top?

When it comes to creating your baby registry you want a smooth and easy process that is also a lot of fun.

Universal registries like Babylist makes the process easy for you and your guests. Then there is Amazon’s baby registry which is not only universal but has the largest selection of products available, often at great discounts.

If you’re deciding between a Babylist vs Amazon registry, it comes down to your preferences and which will work the best for you. We’ve broken down the features of both Babylist and Amazon so you can compare the two registries and decide for yourself. Keep reading to find out which registry option is your perfect fit.

Related Article: Target vs Amazon baby Registry – Which one is Right for You?

Throw a Virtual Baby Shower so Everyone Can Celebrate!

Free Trial – 14-Day Refund for any reason
• Only 1 Minute Setup!
• 80+ Custom Themes & Matching Invites
• Use Any Online Registry
Send Unlimited Invites and Updates
• Baby Shower Games with Scoreboards, Give Prizes!

Build Your Shower

Babylist Vs Amazon Registry: Comparing Features

Let’s take a look at the features of both the Babylist and Amazon registries in more detail. Each registry has similar features, but also a few unique offerings as well. We’re looking at personalization, perks, functionality, and gift options across both brands to see how they stack up.

Personalization Options

You want a baby registry that is unique to you and your needs. Whether that means having easy access to all your registry items in one location, the ability for guests to gift services like a home-cooked meal, or to help you save for college. Each family is different, which means not every baby registry will work for everyone. We’ve compared the personalization options of both Babylist and Amazon.

Babylist

Babylist offers a more personal approach to your registry. Their site has access to hundreds of the most popular baby products, including the vast majority of products featured on our best-of lists. You can also add any items from any store to your Babylist registry. That can mean a stroller from a big box store or a hand-woven wall hanging from an artist on Etsy.

You can add services to your registry as well, including pet sitting, homemade meals, or request second-hand items. With Babylist, family and friends can also contribute to a cash fund for college or other needs.

babylist vs amazon

Amazon

It’s no secret that Amazon has one of the largest selections of items all in one place. You can find everything you need for mom and baby from a variety of different sellers.

You can also add gifts to your registry from anywhere, not just from Amazon. With the Amazon Assistant extension, you can add items to your registry from any website.

babylist vs amazon

Discounts and Perks

When looking at the Babylist vs Amazon registry, it’s important to know how discounts and perks can save you money. If you have a few more items left on your registry when your baby arrives, you’ll receive a discount on those items with both Amazon and Babylist. And every parent knows those added savings can help out a ton.

Dive deeper into our Amazon baby registry review to see if it’s the right choice for you.

Babylist

With your Babylist registry, you’ll receive a 15% completion discount starting 60 days before your baby’s due date. You have up to 6 months after your baby’s due date to use the discount.

This discount can only be used one time and is only eligible for items sold through the Babylist store. Any items added to your registry from other stores are not eligible for the discount. It also does not apply to gift cards, shipping and handling fees, and select brands.

babylist vs amazon

Amazon

Amazon offers a 10% discount on registry items or 15% for Prime members. The completion discount is eligible on remaining baby registry items within 60 days of the baby’s due date (before it or after it). You can use the discount on up to two orders with a combined item total of $2,000.

The baby registry diaper discount helps parents save even more with 20% off eligible diapers for one year. This discount unlocks when you reach $500 in purchases from your registry.

With Amazon, you can also enter for a chance to win your entire registry for free.

babylist vs amazon

Ease of Use

While it’s wonderful to have a registry with a plethora of items to choose from, it also needs to be easy for you and your loved ones to use. A complicated format can leave you frustrated when you’re setting up your registry.

What’s more, if friends and family can’t easily navigate through your list, you might end up with more gift cards and fewer items from your registry. Let’s see how easy it’s to use Babylist and Amazon.

Babylist

No matter what item you want on your registry, you can add it from any site with Babylist. Use Babylist’s browser extension to add anything to your registry from other stores with the click of a button. This makes it super simple to build your registry and include everything you need.

Loved ones will see all of your items organized in one place on a beautifully laid out website. They can sort by gift price, store, and which items are on your must-have list.

babylist vs amazon

Amazon

Most people are already familiar with shopping on Amazon, but did you know that the Amazon baby registry is conveniently located on Amazon’s website?

This makes it super easy for loved ones to easily purchase gifts on a platform with which they are already familiar.

Similar to Babylist, you can sort registry gifts by price, what is still needed and which items are a must-have for mom, making the shopping experience even easier. Loved ones who are Prime members will also benefit from fast and free shipping on many items in your registry.

babylist vs amazon

Mobile App Functionality

With most people using their phones for just about everything, having easy access to your registry on the go is important. A mobile app that is easy to use means you can add gifts to your registry at any time. Gift-givers should also be able to easily shop from your registry using a mobile app.

Babylist

Babylist has an attractive mobile app that is easy to navigate, which is a big bonus. Browse through your registry, add items and share your list with loved ones right from your phone. This makes it easy for you and your guests to track and purchase your gifts.

Amazon

The Amazon baby registry is part of the Amazon mobile app, so it’s easily accessible by anyone who has an Amazon account. This makes the process of shopping for a registry on the go even easier since many people already have the app on their phones.

Checkout Experience

In the same way that adding items to your registry should be a seamless process, purchasing those gifts should be easy as well. If friends and family have to bop around to different sites for your gifts, it can be complicated and confusing. You want the checkout experience to be as simple as possible, which will ensure you’ll receive more of the gifts you need.

Babylist

As we mentioned before, you can easily see all of the registry items in one place with Babylist – a super useful feature for expectant parents.

However, gift-givers are sometimes frustrated by the checkout experience, it has to be noted. One drawback is if someone purchases a gift from another store, they have to go to the site to purchase the gift and then go back to Babylist to mark it as purchased. It would be nice to see some sort of integration where purchases can be made via the registry in future.

Amazon

Amazon has one of the easiest checkout experiences out there. You can scroll through the registry and easily click “add to cart” without having to click on the product. Once you’re ready to checkout you can select gift wrapping options and ship straight to the mom-to-be. Amazon also offers a “buy now” button that lets you skip the checkout process altogether if you’re already signed in.

Cash Gifts

You may need to purchase some items on your registry yourself. You might also want to kick-start your child’s college fund or a savings account. This is where cash gifts are incredibly helpful.

babylist vs amazon

Babylist

Babylist allows you to create cash funds so friends and family can contribute any amount they choose towards important big-ticket costs. They pay with a debit or credit card and Babylist transfers the money to your PayPal account.

Amazon

While you can give an Amazon gift card, cash gifts are not available through Amazon. Gift givers who want to give monetarily will need to find another avenue.

Freebies

It’s great to get freebies, especially if you’re expecting a little one! But do Amazon and Babylist even offer freebies, and if so – how do they compare?

Babylist

With Babylist you’ll receive the Hello Baby Box full of goodies. Items can include baby wipes, diaper sample packs, nursing pads, baby bottles, swaddle blankets, and more. To receive the box, you’ll need to add at least three items to your registry from the Babylist shop, make a minimum $10 purchase from the Babylist shop, and pay $9.95 plus tax for shipping.

babylist vs amazon

Amazon

Amazon’s baby registry welcome box is full of $30-35 worth of goodies. To receive the box, you must be a Prime member, complete 60% of your checklist, and purchase at least $10 from the registry (the purchase can be made by you or a loved one).

The box contents change over time and can include a pacifier, baby wipes, lactation snacks, burp cloths, prenatal vitamins, baby shampoo, a onesie, and other items.

babylist vs amazon

Group Gifting

Do you have a big-ticket item on your registry that might be too expensive for someone to purchase on their own? Group gifting allows multiple people to pitch in on higher-priced items like strollers, car seats, and cribs.

Both Amazon and Babylist allow group gifting. With both registries, loved ones can contribute as much as they’d like toward a gift, which will come to the mom-to-be in the form of a gift card she can use to purchase the item.

Read: 11 Best Eco-Friendly Baby Shower Gifts for Natural -Minded Parents-to-Be

Our Takeaway

When it comes to comparing the Babylist vs Amazon registry, Amazon is a clear winner when it comes to discounts, platform familiarity, and item options.

Babylist comes out on top when it comes to personalization and a visually appealing platform. Having the ability to contribute meals and babysitting is invaluable to so many moms.

Both are universal registries, which lets you add items from any website to build the registry of your dreams.

Ultimately the baby registry you choose is up to your personal preference. If you’re looking for a familiar site that offers the largest selection of baby items and discounts on diapers then Amazon is for you.

A mom-to-be who wants the option to request services and cash contributions toward a future college fund might consider Babylist for her registry.

Related Articles:

webbabyshower team jacqueline mann

Jacqueline Mann is a freelance content writer with more than 10 years of experience in the communications field. In her free time, she enjoys trips to the library with her son, watching anime with her husband, and relaxing with a weekly yoga practice.

Related Articles
image
Baby Shower Registry Tips

How to Get Free Diapers: The Ultimate Guide

Introduction to Getting Free Diapers Get ready for a game-changing revelation! Hold on to your baby booties because we're about to drop some exciting news:…

image
Baby Shower Registry Tips

What Is a Diaper Fund and How To Include It In Your Baby Shower Registry Plans

What is a Diaper Fund? Interested in a diaper fund but not certain what it means? Look no further, we have all the answers you…

image
Baby Shower Registry Tips

Amazon Diaper Fund How To Set Up Guide : Shower Parents With Essentials

If you’re looking for a simple way to support a new mom, you’ve come to the right place! Amazon offers a terrific method for expecting…

image
Baby Shower Registry Tips

11 Best Baby Registries in 2024 – Which One is Best for You?

Are you expecting a new baby soon? If so, then you’ve probably already figured out there are tons of online & virtual baby registries to…

Free Demo